Two award-winning New Zealand authors have had their books disqualified from consideration for the country's esteemed literary award because of the use of AI in designing their book covers.
Disqualification Particulars
Stephanie Johnson's story compilation "Obligate Carnivore" and Elizabeth Smither's novella set "Angel Train" were entered for the 2026 Ockham book awards and its $65,000 New Zealand dollar novel award in October, but were ruled out the next month due to recently introduced rules concerning artificial intelligence usage.
The publishing house of the two titles, Quentin Wilson, stated that the prize organizers amended the criteria in August, by which time the covers for every submitted title would have previously been completed.
“It was, therefore, far too late for any publisher to have taken this clause into account in their design briefs,” the publisher noted.
Authors' Reactions
Johnson expressed sympathy for the prize administrators, saying she shares serious worries about AI in artistic industries, but was disappointed by the decision.
“It would be untrue to claim I am not upset by this,” she remarked. “It’s my 22nd book, and it is my fourth collection of short stories. These stories … were written over a sort of 20 year period, so for me, it’s quite an important book.”
She added that authors typically have minimal involvement in cover design and was unaware AI had been used for her book cover, which features a cat with human teeth.
“I just thought it was a photograph of a real cat and the teeth had been superimposed, but apparently it wasn’t,” the author explained, adding that unlike younger generations, she finds it difficult to recognize computer-created images.
Johnson feared that readers might assume she employed artificial intelligence to write her work, which she emphatically did not do.
“Instead of talking about my book … and what the inspiration was, we are talking about bloody AI, which I hate.”
In a comment, Smither said that the designers spent hours crafting her book's art, which features a locomotive and an celestial figure partially hidden by smoke, inspired by painter Marc Chagall's imagery.
“My primary concern is for the designers: their careful, detailed work … is not being respected,” Smither stated.
Award Committee's Stance
The trust chair, head of the book awards trust that oversees the Ockham awards, affirmed the organization takes a strong position on the application of artificial intelligence in books.”
“The trust does not take lightly a decision that prevents the latest works of two of New Zealand’s most esteemed writers from being considered for the 2026 award,” she said.
“Nevertheless, the rules apply equally to every participant, no matter their standing, and must be enforced uniformly.”
The decision to amend the artificial intelligence criteria was motivated by a desire to support the artistic and intellectual property rights of the nation's writers and illustrators, she explained.
“As AI evolves, there may well be a need for the trust to revisit and develop the criteria further.”
Industry Considerations
Wilson pointed out that publishers and authors often use tools like grammar checkers and image editors, which incorporate AI, and this incident underscored the urgent need for carefully crafted policies.
“Our industry must collaborate to prevent a recurrence of this scenario.”
Both Smither and Stephanie Johnson have in the past served as judges for categories of the Ockham awards, and both stressed that covers get little attention during judging.
“The contents and the close reading were everything,” Smither concluded.
The use of AI in artistic fields has faced growing examination as the technology advances, with some groups creating ways to address its influence.